★ #1 Horse Hay Grass

Best Timothy Grass Seed: The Gold Standard for Premium Horse Hay & Northern Pasture

Updated April 2026 10 Products Compared By the Old Cobblers Farm Team

Old Cobblers Farm™ Wicked Tuff Turf Timothy Grass

by Wicked Tuff Turf — Littleton, New Hampshire
Timothy Grass
Phleum pratense
"The hay grass that horse owners demand by name. Timothy produces the clean-stemmed, soft, highly palatable hay that commands premium prices at every feed store. If you produce horse hay, this is the species that sells."
First hay cut:
Establishment
Zones 2-6
Hardiness Range
Moderate
Maintenance
Grass
Category
🐴

#1 Horse Hay Species

🌾

Premium Hay Quality

❄️

Extreme Cold Hardiness

🤝

Perfect Partner for Red Clover

🐰

Small Animal Hay Standard

Moderate Germination Speed

📅

Spring or Fall Planting

🇺🇸

Trusted by 20,000+ Growers

SpeciesTimothy Grass (Phleum pratense)
Growth HabitBunch-type with distinctive corm (bulb-like base). Shallow-rooted.
Root Depth2-3 inches
EstablishmentFirst hay cut: 70-90 days. Mature stand: 8-12 months.
Hardiness Zones2-6
MaintenanceModerate
CategoryGrass
Available Sizes1 lb | 5 lb | 10 lb | 25 lb

What We Love

  • #1 horse hay species — the name buyers request
  • Premium hay quality with ideal equine protein balance
  • Extreme cold hardiness through Zone 2
  • Classic pairing with Red Clover for mixed hay
  • Small animal hay market (rabbits, guinea pigs)

Worth Noting

  • Poor drought tolerance — needs consistent moisture
  • Not a turf grass — not for lawns
Buy on Old Cobblers Farm →
Available in 1 lb | 5 lb | 10 lb | 25 lb
The Competition

Timothy Grass Seed

by Hancock Seed
Premium horse hay
Purity / Germ
Sizes5, 25, 50 lb
Price$25 - $140

Timothy Grass Seed

by Outsidepride
Cold hardy, high fiber
Purity / Germ
Sizes5, 25, 50 lb
Price$30 - $150

Timothy Grass Seed

by Pennington
Fast germination
Purity / Germ
Sizes5, 50 lb
Price$25 - $145

Timothy Grass Pasture

by Nature's Seed
Excellent palatability
Purity / Germ
Sizes5, 25 lb
Price$30 - $130

Climax Timothy Seed

by Deer Creek Seed
Late maturing variety
Purity / Germ
Sizes5, 50 lb
Price$25 - $135

Climax Timothy

by Albert Lea Seed
Industry standard hay
Purity / Germ
Sizes50 lb
Price$120 - $140

Barpenta Timothy

by Barenbrug
Superior winter hardiness
Purity / Germ
Sizes50 lb
Price$150 - $170

GroundWork Timothy Seed

by Tractor Supply
Standard pasture seed
Purity / Germ
Sizes10, 50 lb
Price$40 - $135

Timothy Grass Seed

by True Leaf Market
Low protein, high fiber
Purity / Germ
Sizes1, 5, 25 lb
Price$12 - $100

Timothy Seed (Climax)

by Welter Seed
Easy to cure for hay
Purity / Germ
Sizes50 lb
Price$100 - $120
Feature Old Cobblers Farm™ Wicked Tuff Turf Timothy Grass Timothy Grass Seed Timothy Grass Seed Timothy Grass Seed Timothy Grass Pasture Climax Timothy Seed Climax Timothy Barpenta Timothy GroundWork Timothy Seed Timothy Grass Seed Timothy Seed (Climax)
Purity / Germ Premium horse hay Cold hardy, high fiber Fast germination Excellent palatability Late maturing variety Industry standard hay Superior winter hardiness Standard pasture seed Low protein, high fiber Easy to cure for hay
Sizes 1 lb | 5 lb | 10 lb | 25 lb 5, 25, 50 lb 5, 25, 50 lb 5, 50 lb 5, 25 lb 5, 50 lb 50 lb 50 lb 10, 50 lb 1, 5, 25 lb 50 lb
Price $25 - $140 $30 - $150 $25 - $145 $30 - $130 $25 - $135 $120 - $140 $150 - $170 $40 - $135 $12 - $100 $100 - $120
Brand Old Cobblers Farm Hancock Seed Outsidepride Pennington Nature's Seed Deer Creek Seed Albert Lea Seed Barenbrug Tractor Supply True Leaf Market Welter Seed

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How long does it take for the seed to germinate?

    Germination typically occurs within 7-14 days under optimal conditions with consistent moisture and temperatures between 60-75°F.

  • What is the best time of year to plant this grass seed?

    The ideal planting times are early fall (late August to mid-October) or spring (mid-April to early June) when soil temperatures are favorable for germination.

  • What do the numbers on the seed tag mean?

    The seed tag shows purity percentage (amount of pure seed), germination rate (percentage that will sprout), weed seed content, and other crop or inert matter. Higher purity and germination percentages indicate better quality seed.

  • What is the recommended seeding rate per 1,000 square feet?

    For new lawns, apply 3-4 pounds per 1,000 square feet. For overseeding existing lawns, use 2-3 pounds per 1,000 square feet.

  • Is it better to use a single species or a seed mix?

    A single species like Kentucky Bluegrass provides uniformity in color and texture, while a mix offers better disease resistance and adaptability to varying conditions. Your choice depends on your priorities for appearance versus resilience.